My Thoughts:
I've made some posts on gaming clips tools like this before, and it seems that I always find myself falling back to Crossclip. Out of this category of tools, this one is the most reliable. I wanted to rate it higher at a 4 star, but they have not updated it significantly for years.
It lacks many of the features of the other tools on the market, but it is the most minimalist and consistent tool, whereas some of the others take too many steps to get the job done.